Tackling Homelessness: Slab City or Bombs?

I was in an rideshare when a gentleman with holes in his jeans and at least four missing teeth got in.  The overwhelming aroma of Mary Jane’s sweet perfume was clinging to his dirty shirt with all the desperation of a lonely barfly.  He looked and smelled like he was out on the streets.  

Now, I always stand to gain from the insights of a casual conversation with a stranger, especially when the reciprocating party appears to have lived a hard life. So, when he brought up the topic of homelessness, my ears perked up. 

I asked him, “How do you think we should fix it?”

Suffice it to say, I was shocked when he said with a completely straight face, “Take them out to the country and bomb ’em!”

“Bomb them!?” I exclaimed.  “Somehow, I don’t think anyone’s going to sign off on that…”

Well, come to find out, after twenty minutes in the car with this guy, he’d never been homeless.  In fact, he made it clear that he detested anyone who he perceived to have given up on their own lives…  While he’d encountered plenty of hardships over his forty five years on Earth, he was of the mindset that if he could lift himself out of despair, anyone could. 

Contrast that with a different gentleman I spoke with who had a clean shirt, ironed slacks and a mouth full of pearly whites. He seemed like a respectable member of society.  Surely, he would agree that escaping destitution is a matter of sheer willpower and nothing more… 

When we started talking, though, I quickly noticed that bad grammar was an unflattering compliment to a noticeable speech impediment.  My suspicions were further confirmed when he said that he knew exactly how hard it was to “get clean” and “pull yourself up out of the gutter.”  Indeed, he had been homeless before…  

In fact, he spent just over four years on the streets before he managed to get a job and find a place to live. He reiterated, however, that he never would have been able to do it on his own.

“The thing that people don’t realize,” he said, “is how hard it is to get out of that cycle when you’re in it…  Drugs are everywhere and they take you. I mean, there were people who had good jobs one day who ended up being homeless the next because one thing led to another and they couldn’t afford to make ends meet anymore.  Not even they could stay off the drugs. You’re surrounded by it.”

He went on to tell me that he couldn’t judge anyone for the position they were in.  

“The guys you see out there talking to street signs…  People don’t understand–they’re doing that because they’re lonely.  I mean, yeah, the drugs don’t help, but most of the time there’s something else going on; mental health and total isolation.  The drugs just make it worse.  People want to escape.”

“So, what’s the solution?” I asked.

Twenty seconds later, when I was starting to think I’d lost his attention to the memory of higher times, he asked, “Have you ever heard of Slab City?”

Now, of course, I didn’t want to appear ignorant, so I laughed awkwardly and nodded.  Then I asked, “Do you think that’s the fix?”

Here’s what he said:

“It’s tough to say…  I mean, people need help getting out of that situation.  I was in it with my girl, so at least I had someone.  I stayed up at night so she could get some sleep, because, ya’ know, there’s always someone tryin’ to steal your shit.  Then, she would be awake during the day…  It’s a lot safer during the day, especially for women.  That way I could get some sleep.  But, we didn’t want to be there.

“Some people just don’t want to participate in the system, though, ya know?  Shit’s so expensive, and a lot of people don’t want to deal with paying bills nonstop.  That’s what Slab City’s all about.  It’s for people who want to live outside of mainstream society.  I think it can be good for a lot of them.  For everyone else, though, I’m not sure…”

With my curiosity piqued, I did some digging and discovered that “Slab City” is an unincorporated plot of land in southern California where people choose to live off-grid, with no access to utilities.  For the most part, it’s self-governed, though the Imperial County Sheriff still regularly patrols the area.  Also, ironically enough, the state provides a good amount of assistance to help the residents survive.

Ultimately, it appeals to people who want to live a transient lifestyle–those who make the conscious decision to sleep out under the stars, of which, there are apparently quite a few.  What about those who are tied to homelessness by circumstance, though-the ones who didn’t make the choice?

For that, I have to consider the words of my toothless friend.  The one who suggested using weapons of war to cleanse our cities.

“There are programs out there that people can take advantage of,” he argued.  “They just might not know about them.”

“Do you think it would help if there were some kind of outreach to get the word out?”  I asked.

“Oh, absolutely!  You know, do that–get the word out–and then do something to clean up the drugs…  I think that would help a lot.”

 “So, no bombs?”

He laughed.  “No, maybe we don’t bomb them…  But, everyone has to understand that some people are beyond help.  Like, maybe we make the changes now to help future generations, but the people who are already caught up in it might just have to live out their lives and die on the street.  Maybe the best we can hope for is a lot less homeless people in the future.”

What do you think?  Is it possible to overcome homelessness in the richest country on Earth?  I’d love to hear your thoughts!


Resources:

  • Immediate Housing Assistance through the state connects those in need with resources for  emergency shelter, food, rental assistance, healthcare, and more.
  • Path Home empowers families with children to get back into housing.


Discover more from The Dantian Project

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

11 responses to “Tackling Homelessness: Slab City or Bombs?”

  1. causticcowboy Avatar
    causticcowboy

    I think an argument can be made that by focusing on domestic production and bringing manufacturing jobs back to the United States, more homeless people will be able to bring in an income. From what I know, many people on the streets feel a lack of purpose, which is what leads them into drug addiction in the first place.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. unabashedly3f763e25a3 Avatar
      unabashedly3f763e25a3

      I wonder if it’s that there aren’t enough jobs, or that a lot of people don’t want to work…

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Beth Avatar
    Beth

    Great post! I think there are various and often intertwining factors for why people become, and in some cases stay, homeless. Mental health, PTSD, and mental illness are prevalent factors. Self medicating to treat those things are another big issue. Drug addiction is a massive factor. Some people it is lack of skills and job opportunity or even loss of income temporarily. Some are fleeing domestic violence situation and don’t have anywhere to go. Several of my veteran friends have been homeless or, but for a friend or family member stepping in, would have been. 

    Some folks just prefer to live outside the boundaries of society, and the level of support that the government should offer people who are homeless by choice is a fair question. Because there are so many overlapping factors in homelessness, the possible solutions are complex. But I think the most important thing to remember is that each individual has different life experiences and complicated factors that intersect to create their situation and it’s important to treat each person as an individual rather than homelessness as an amorphous issue to solve.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. unabashedly3f763e25a3 Avatar
      unabashedly3f763e25a3

      Good point(s)… Individual experiences add to the complexity and everyone needs to be looked at in a unique light. Still, I wonder if the overall issue can be categorized into common characteristics. Like drug use, as an example- if there are common reasons as to why people end up addicted- or educational disparities- if there’s evidence that points to why large swaths of people lack marketable job skills- Maybe there are commonalities that can be identified. If so, then it might be possible to treat those individually, which could help to at least improve the situation.

      Maybe it requires getting boots on the ground in the form of case workers to triage who’s who (the people making the choice to be homeless vs. the ones trying to get out of it). Or maybe there are policies and laws that could be passed to make changes on a grand scale (assuming our government can work together for more than two seconds!) Part of me wants to think that a happy, healthy society won’t have nearly as much homelessness, regardless of whatever individual situations people are in, just like happy healthy bodies don’t have cancer at the same rate as unhealthy ones do…

      Liked by 1 person

  3. speedilyexpert3bdc0d1402 Avatar
    speedilyexpert3bdc0d1402

    Great post! It seems like there are three main reasons as to why someone would experience homelessness. They are choosing to opt out of society, they have fallen on hard times and need help, or they have just given up on themselves.  

    The answer to overcoming homelessness is multifaceted and several systemic issues are contributing to the rising numbers.  However, I think there are a few causes in the U.S. to consider.  

    Employment and Economic Factors: A lot of jobs today seem to lack meaning and purpose. Combined with debt and housing being at an all-time high, people can feel crushed by the burden of staying afloat.  

    Healthcare: Access and cost are contributing to people not getting the care they need. Support services are sometimes limited, making it harder for people to get back on their feet.  

    Community and Connection: Having support from friends, family and your employer is critical to overcoming hardships. A sense of community seems to be diminishing as our cities grow, we adopt busier lifestyles, and people move towards virtual communication.  

    Any ideas on how we can solve these issues?  

    Liked by 2 people

    1. cool49a739991fc Avatar
      cool49a739991fc

      Sooner or later we need to face the question of resources and the fact that our government can’t agree on anything. All of these are good observations, but who’s going to pay for it? Other countries like Denmark and have much lower rates of homelessness, but that’s because their taxes are so much higher, which affords them more social safety net programs (which I don’t see Americans voting for).

      Vietnam also has lower rates of homelessness, but that’s largely because they are in a situation where their costs of production are so much lower that everyone has a job. Plus, in both countries, there’s a stronger sense of community, which can work to build a sense of “duty”.

      I think part of the issue in the US is that people feel ok with exploiting the system. They don’t feel like they’re ripping off their fellow countrymen the way they would in these other countries. There’s not a common sense of pride for just being “American”. At least not like there is in smaller, rural communities.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. goateecheerfullyec02e945d9 Avatar
    goateecheerfullyec02e945d9

    Experiments are ongoing to combat homelessness. Unfortunately it is a charged topic because of political bias toward entitlements and socialism.
    Here are some examples of studies done on Universal Basic Income and Dividend:
    US:
    https://www.givedirectly.org/2023-ubi-results
    https://earth4all.life/views/the-alaska-permanent-fund
    Primary sources for this fund:
    https://apfc.org/
    https://pfd.alaska.gov/FAQ#:~:text=What%20are%20the%20eligibility%20requirements,you%20apply%20for%20a%20dividend.
    Unicef Study in India:
    http://www.bin-italia.org/UP/pubb/cashtransferindia.pdf
    Philanthropic study in Germany:
    https://www.thetimes.com/world/europe/article/germany-universal-basic-income-experiment-p3jgscm35

    Homelessness has many causes. One is the lack of affordable housing.
    Every taxpayer (or household for those married filling jointly) should only be allowed to own 2 houses. Eliminate the “industrial rental market” and require only citizens to own a house to live in and a house to vacation at and voila our supply problem will be gone overnight. It is estimated that 2% of all houses are owned by a non-citizen living overseas and 10% are owned by a corporation with the intent on renting. That is 16 million homes. That is not including the number of homes owned by citizens that own more than 2 homes. People could still rent out their home or a vacation home but owning 5+ rental homes only eliminates equity that others should be building in order to be financially resilient.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. cool49a739991fc Avatar
      cool49a739991fc

      Sure, there political reasons why homelessness exists, but there’s also the fact that a lot of people flat out don’t want to be helped… They like the violence and having to scrape to get by. It’s like that’s what gives them meaning in their lives.

      So, I don’t actually think its a fixable problem as long as our system works the way it does. That’s why so many people like what Trump is doing- he’s shaking up the system, and if it means that parts of it break, then so be it because something has to change.

      Like

    2. cool49a739991fc Avatar
      cool49a739991fc

      Sure, there political reasons why homelessness exists, but there’s also the fact that a lot of people flat out don’t want to be helped… They like the violence and having to scrape to get by. It’s like that’s what gives them meaning in their lives.

      So, I don’t actually think its a fixable problem as long as our system works the way it does. That’s why so many people like what Trump is doing- he’s shaking up the system, and if it means that parts of it break, then so be it because something has to change.

      Like

  5.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    As a former case worker who worked with homeless people, I can say that the majority of them wouldn’t be able to function in mainstream society at all… They’re either too far gone with drugs, or too set in the ways of living on the street.

    Like

  6. Government Inefficiency: The Three-Legged Table – The Dantian Project Avatar

    […] Tackling Homelessness: Slab City or Bombs, which discussed the epidemic of homelessness in America, implied that government is needed to […]

    Like

Leave a comment

Dastem

A student of life, seeking truth in a world of lies and illumination in a world of shadows, Dastem’s writing is both provocative and engaging.

His mission behind The Dantian Project is to find the center of what makes us each truly and uniquely human.

Let’s connect

Discover more from The Dantian Project

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading